China’s Climate Paradox: A Leader in Coal and Clean Energy


As world leaders collect in Spain to debate the right way to sluggish the warming of the planet, a highlight falls on China — the highest emitter of greenhouse gases.

China burns about half the coal used globally annually. Between 2000 and 2018, its annual carbon emissions almost tripled, and it now accounts for about 30% of the world’s complete. Yet it is also the main marketplace for photo voltaic panels, wind generators and electrical autos, and it manufactures about two-thirds of photo voltaic cells put in worldwide.

“We are witnessing many contradictions in China’s energy development,” mentioned Kevin Tu, a Beijing-based fellow with the Center on Global Energy Policy at Columbia University. “It’s the largest coal market and the largest clean energy market in the world.”

That obvious paradox is feasible due to the sheer scale of China’s power calls for.

FILE – A photo voltaic panel set up is seen in Ruicheng County in central China’s Shanxi Province, Nov. 27, 2019.

But as China’s financial system slows to the bottom degree in 1 / 4 century — round 6% development, in line with authorities statistics — policymakers are doubling down on help for coal and different heavy industries, the normal backbones of China’s power system and financial system. At the identical time, the nation is lowering subsidies for renewable power.

At the annual United Nations local weather summit, this 12 months in Madrid, authorities representatives will put the ending touches on implementing the 2015 Paris Agreement, which set a purpose to restrict future warming to 1.5 to 2 levels Celsius above pre-industrial ranges. Nations could determine for themselves the right way to obtain it.

China had beforehand dedicated to shifting its power combine to 20% renewables, together with nuclear and hydroelectric power. Climate consultants typically agree that the preliminary targets pledged in Paris won’t be sufficient to succeed in the purpose, and subsequent 12 months nations are required to articulate extra formidable targets.

Hopes that China would provide to do rather more are fading.

Recent media experiences and satellite tv for pc photos recommend that China is constructing or planning to finish new coal energy vegetation with complete capability of 148 gigawatts — almost equal to your entire coal-power capability of the European Union inside the subsequent few years, in line with an evaluation by Global Energy Monitor, a San Francisco-based nonprofit.

Separately, funding in China’s renewable power dropped nearly 40 p.c in the primary half of 2019 in contrast with the identical interval final 12 months, in line with Bloomberg New Energy Finance, a analysis group. The authorities slashed subsidies for photo voltaic power.

Last week in Beijing, China’s vice minister of ecology and setting advised reporters that non-fossil-fuel sources already account for 14.3% of the nation’s power combine. He didn’t point out that China would embrace extra stringent targets quickly.

“We are still faced with challenges of developing our economy, improving people’s livelihood,” Zhao Yingmin mentioned.

China is alternately forged because the world’s worst local weather villain or its potential clean-energy savior, however each superlatives are considerably misplaced.

A man wears a mask on Tiananmen Square in thick haze in Beijing Tuesday, Jan. 29, 2013. Extremely high pollution levels shrouded eastern China for the second time in about two weeks.  (AP Photo/Ng Han Guan)FILE – A man wears a masks on Tiananmen Square in thick haze in Beijing, Jan. 29, 2013.

As a fast-growing financial system, it was all the time inevitable that China’s power calls for would climb steeply. The solely query was whether or not the nation may energy a sufficiently giant portion of its financial system with renewables to curb emissions development.

Many observers took hope from a short dip in China’s carbon emissions between 2014 and 2016, in addition to Chinese chief Xi Jinping’s assertion in 2017 that China had “taken a driving seat in international cooperation to respond to climate change.”

Renewed give attention to coal

Today the nation’s renewed give attention to coal comes as a disappointment.

“Now there’s a sense that rather than being a leader, China is the one that is out of step,” mentioned Lauri Myllyvirta, lead analyst on the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air in Helsinki. He notes that a number of developed nations — together with Germany, South Korea and the United States — are quickly lowering their reliance on coal energy.

Fossil fuels akin to coal, gasoline and pure fuel launch carbon dioxide into the environment, trapping warmth and altering the local weather. Coal is the most important offender.

Last 12 months, coal consumption in the United States hit the bottom degree in almost 40 years, in line with the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

One place to contemplate the rise, pause and rise once more of China’s coal sector is Shanxi province — an enormous mountainous area in central China.

Shanxi is the center of China’s conventional coal nation, dotted with giant mines, but additionally the location of a number of the nation’s largest photo voltaic and wind-power tasks, in line with state media.

During a lot of the previous 30 years of fast financial development, the coal enterprise boomed in Shanxi and close by provinces. As China’s cities and industries expanded, coal equipped a lot of that energy, and China surpassed the U.S. because the world’s high carbon emitter in 2006.

In this Nov. 28, 2019, photo, smoke and steam rise from a coal processing plant that produces carbon black, an ingredient in…FILE – Smoke and steam rise from a coal processing plant that produces carbon black, an ingredient in metal manufacturing, in Hejin in central China’s Shanxi Province, Nov. 28, 2019.

But after climbing sharply for 20 years, China’s emissions stalled round 2013 and then declined barely in 2015 and 2016, in line with Global Carbon Budget, which tracks emissions worldwide. This dip got here as Chinese leaders declared a “war on pollution” and suspended the development of dozens of deliberate coal energy vegetation, together with some in Shanxi.

At the identical time, the federal government required many present coal operators to put in new gear in smokestacks to take away sulfur dioxide, nitrous oxide and different hazardous substances. About 80% of coal vegetation now have scrubbers, mentioned Alvin Lin, Beijing-based China local weather and power coverage director for the Natural Resources Defense Council, a nonprofit.

As a outcome, the air high quality in many Chinese cities, together with Beijing, improved considerably between 2013 and 2017. Residents lengthy accustomed to carrying face masks and working residence air-filter machines loved a reprieve of extra “blue sky days,” as low-pollution days are identified in China.

Annual ranges of PM 2.5 — a tiny however harmful pollutant — dropped by roughly a 3rd throughout China between 2013 and 2017, from 61.eight to 42 micrograms per cubic meter, in line with scientists at Beijing’s Tsinghua University and different establishments. They made the report in November in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, a peer-reviewed journal.

“That’s a big improvement, although in terms of safe air quality, we’re still not there yet,” Lin mentioned. China’s air pollution ranges are nonetheless effectively above requirements set by the World Health Organization.

While these retrofitted coal vegetation emit fewer pollution that hurt human well being, the scrubbers don’t cut back greenhouse gases. “The new plants are good for air quality, but you still have all that carbon dioxide that goes into the atmosphere,” Lin mentioned.

Carbon emissions rising

In the previous three years, China’s carbon emissions have begun to rise once more, in line with Global Carbon Budget.

That development was evident in the primary half of 2019, when China’s carbon emissions from fossil fuels and concrete manufacturing rose 4%, in contrast with the identical interval final 12 months, in line with Myllyvirta’s preliminary evaluation of Chinese authorities knowledge.

People ride along a street on a smoggy day in Daqing, Heilongjiang province, China, Oct. 21, 2013. FILE – People journey alongside a road on a smoggy day in Daqing, Heilongjiang province, China, Oct. 21, 2013.

The coming winter in Beijing might even see a return of extended smog, as authorities loosen environmental controls on heavy business — in half to compensate for different slowing sectors in the financial system. Cement and metal manufacturing stay each power intensive and closely polluting.

Permits for brand new coal vegetation proliferated after regulatory authority was briefly devolved from Beijing to provincial governments, which see development tasks and coal operations as boosts to native economies and tax bases, mentioned Ted Nace, govt director of Global Energy Monitor.

“It’s as though a boa constructor swallowed a giraffe, and now we’re watching that bulge move through the system,” mentioned Nace. In China, it takes about three years to construct a coal plant.

In November, Premier Li Keqiang gave a speech to policymakers emphasizing the significance of home coal to power safety.

But as a result of China’s coal-power enlargement is rising quicker than power demand, overcapacity “is a serious concern now,” mentioned Columbia University’s Tu.

And as soon as new infrastructure is constructed, it is exhausting to disregard.

“It will be politically difficult to tear down a brand-new coal plant that’s employing people and supporting a mining operation. It will make it more difficult for China to transition away from coal,” Nace mentioned.

Reliance on China

The world has already warmed by 1 diploma Celsius. All eventualities envisioned by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for holding planetary warming to round 1.5 levels Celsius contain steep worldwide reductions in coal-power technology.

In that effort, different nations depend on China to fabricate a lot of the photo voltaic panels put in worldwide, in line with an evaluation in the journal Science co-authored by Jonas Nahm, an power skilled at Johns Hopkins University.

“If we have any chance to meet climate targets, we have to do a lot by 2030 — and we won’t be able to do it without China’s clean-energy supply chain,” Nahm mentioned.

China’s manufacturing helped deliver down the price of photo voltaic panels by 80% between 2008 and 2013. Prices for wind generators and lithium-ion batteries additionally dropped considerably, in line with Bloomberg New Energy Finance.

“China has a really mixed record. On the one hand, it’s seen rapidly rising emissions over the past two decades,” Nahm mentioned. “On the other hand, it’s shown it’s able to innovate around manufacturing — and make new energy technologies available at scale, faster and cheaper.”



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here