Germany’s Labor System Would Be Difficult to Import to U.S.


MUNICH, Germany—Some Democratic presidential candidates need to convey parts of German labor relations to the U.S. While that might seem engaging on the floor, doing so can be tough and the financial payoff unsure.

Labor unions are way more prevalent in Germany than within the U.S. below a system referred to as Sozialpartnerschaft, or social partnership. It has followers amongst each company leaders and unions right here. The system is credited with giving German staff job safety and a higher voice in how firms are run. But labor specialists view it as a uniquely German system developed when manufacturing giants dominated the economic system.

“A model like Sozialpartnerschaft that has grown over decades is based on many economic, cultural and social aspects,” mentioned Solveigh Hieronimus, a McKinsey & Co. accomplice in Munich who advises on labor-market methods. “It is probably not easily transferable to other countries.”

The German system has two essential options that separate it from the U.S.

One is works councils—worker representatives who’ve a say in firm administration. In giant German corporations, these staff maintain half the seats on company boards, to which the chief govt studies. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D., Mass.), a Democratic presidential candidate, has proposed laws that will require giant U.S. firms to have labor representatives on company boards, saying that will maintain corporations extra accountable to staff and communities the place they function.

Such councils have been criticized by enterprise teams for drawing out choice making round reorganizations or adoption of latest expertise at a time when German firms are going through competitors from Asia and the U.S.

“There’s a big contradiction between the needs of the union and the needs of the company,” mentioned Bertram Brossardt, chief govt of the Bavarian Industry Association.

The different key characteristic of the German system is sectorwide contracts. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I., Vt.), one other candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, has supported this with the purpose of extending the higher pay and advantages acquired by union members to extra U.S. staff.


Which parts of German labor would you want to see applied within the U.S.? Join the dialog under.

German enterprise associations negotiate labor contracts with unions that apply to a number of employers in an trade, resembling metallic processing or grocery shops. The result’s that even nonunionized companies usually comply with the wage construction agreed to within the contract for his or her trade.

In the U.S., such sectoral contracts would require a big rewrite of labor regulation, a tough prospect in a divided Congress. Under present regulation, U.S. companies typically can’t work collectively. While unions symbolize staff at a number of employers, they have to negotiate contracts with particular person corporations. Sectoral contracts discourage worker motion between corporations as a result of they’re unlikely to obtain a increase by taking a job at a competitor.

The German labor system deserves some credit score for an extended interval of postwar prosperity, mentioned Thomas Griebe, a Hamburg-based employment legal professional at Vangard Littler who represents administration. He mentioned that’s partly as a result of an in depth relationship between administration and staff has allowed simpler concessions throughout financial slowdowns.

But if the works-council system didn’t exist right now, he doubts Germans can be clamoring to create it.

“The current system is not in line with the modern world of working,” he mentioned. “The system creates more costs for the firms, and the benefits of the system are hard to calculate.”

German wages have grown extra slowly than U.S. wages since 2000, although Germany has greater unionization charges. In 2000, German staff earned 109% the typical wage of U.S. staff, when adjusting for foreign money variations. Now they earn 99% of the wage paid to U.S. staff, in accordance to knowledge from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. Comparing whole compensation is tough as a result of German staff obtain well being care and extra beneficiant retirement advantages from the federal government.

While the German system has gained reward from some U.S. politicians, unionization charges in Germany have fallen as its economic system faces pressures from lower-cost overseas labor and a transfer towards less-unionized fields, resembling data expertise.

German labor leaders, nevertheless, say they their system has clear advantages.

“Workers in the U.S. are definitely at risk,” mentioned

Frank Bsirske,

the lately retired chairman of Germany’s United Services Union. “The level of security, the level of sustainability, the level of working conditions are significantly higher in Germany.”

U.S. labor-market fluctuations have downsides for some staff. But the American system has aided within the creation of among the world’s main expertise corporations and supported a decadelong stretch of financial progress, whereas Europe’s economic system has grown in suits and begins.

Another problem to bringing a German-style system to the U.S.: There is a small base of unionized staff to construct it on. In the U.S., 12% of U.S. staff had been represented by labor unions in 2018, in accordance to the Labor Department.

In distinction, 46% of Germans work for employers topic to collective-bargaining agreements negotiated by unions, in accordance to the Institute for Employment Research in Nuremberg.

U.S. staff seem to have chosen not to comply with in Germany’s footsteps, mentioned Mr. Brossardt of the trade affiliation. “To change traditions, I don’t know if it’s possible if the employees don’t want to take part in a union,” he mentioned.

Write to Eric Morath at

Copyright ©2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here